Where to complain about a district court judge

The content of the article

• Legal basis for complaint
• The concept of disciplinary misconduct
• Recipients
• Chairman of the court
• Jury
• High Council of Justice
• Prosecutor’s office
• Administration of the President of the Russian Federation

People administering justice are not always perfect. A judge is primarily a person who has a subjective opinion. Sometimes he can break the law. Some members of the district court exceed their authority. If the judge made a mistake, the plaintiff has the right to complain to him. Where to go when this situation arises.

Legal basis for complaint

You can write a statement on the legality of the work of a judge if his actions violate human rights. For example, when the presiding person is interested in the outcome of a case or a deliberate delays in a lawsuit.

Grounds for complaint:

1. Violation of terms. If more than 2 months have passed since the filing of the claim, but the date of the court session has not been set.
2. Refusal to accept evidence. Applicant Must Confirm Legality of Submission.
3. Illegal execution of the court protocol. The document does not contain important circumstances, testimonies of witnesses and other necessary information. The protocol is illegal if the procedure for its execution is violated: there is no data on the participants in the process or details are missing.
4. Violation of the sequence of proceedings.
5. The representative of the government has family relations with the participants.

The concept of disciplinary misconduct

This concept includes inaction in the performance of duties, abuse of authority, interest in the outcome of the trial. Disciplinary misconduct is a violation by a judge of the norms of the law and the provisions of the code of judicial ethics. Such situations sometimes arise in extracurricular activities, damage the reputation. Exceeding a judge in ordinary life is also a disciplinary offense.

Recipients

According to the legislation of the Russian Federation, any citizen of the country has the right to complain about the unlawful actions of a government official. There is a clear judicial hierarchy in Russia.

If the complaint against the judge about the violation of procedural actions at the district level did not have a result, then the applicant can appeal to a higher authority.

Recipients to whom you can file a claim:

• the chairman of the court;
• judicial board;
• High Council of Justice of the Russian Federation;
• The prosecutor’s office of the Russian Federation;
• Administration of the President of Russia.

Chairman of the court

Subjects with a large population may have several officials performing judicial duties at the district level. Their work is coordinated by the chairman. He establishes internal rules, distributes duties, appoints and dismisses.

Complaining to the chairman of the court is an effective method. It is important not to confuse the statement about the violation of the official’s work and appeal against his decision. These are completely different documents..

Jury

If the chairman of the district court cannot solve the problem himself, he will apply this document to a higher authority. Justice is restored by the qualification panel of judges. She considers such complaints and has the right to make a disciplinary reprimand. The board will conduct an audit, after which it will make a decision on the violation.

High Council of Justice

This is the federal executive authority of the Russian Federation. Along with other functions, it supervises the work of judges, lawyers and notaries. A well-composed and well-grounded complaint may result in disciplinary action. In case of serious violations, a complete termination of the powers of a judge is possible.

Prosecutor’s office

This is a supervisor that resolves conflicts of any interest. If the victim complains to the Russian Prosecutor’s Office, his statement will most likely be redirected to the panel of judges. The reason – the courts of the Russian Federation are independent bodies. Their representatives can be prosecuted in violation of the law. A complaint against a judge to the prosecutor’s office will be considered if the plaintiff suffered material damage.

Administration of the President of the Russian Federation

It is completely legal to complain about the unauthorized actions of a district court judge to this body. The President of the Russian Federation is indirectly responsible for the actions of officials included in the system of the Ministry of Justice. It is important that the appeal is legally competently drafted and correctly executed, all violations have links to Russian legislation. The statement should not contain false accusations.